In coastal Morro Bay, three iconic but defunct smokestacks are slated to be torn down. A lithium battery storage project is planned as state transitions to renewable energy.
Have something to say? Lookout welcomes letters to the editor, within our policies, from readers. Guidelines here.
In this foggy Central Coast fishing town, two icons tower above everything.
One is Morro Rock, the 23-million-year-old plug of an ancient volcano, rising 576 feet out of the sea. The other is a trident of 450-foot concrete smokestacks, built half a century ago for a seaside power plant.
Together, they give Morro Bay its nickname: Three Stacks and a Rock.
Outsiders might see the humble smokestacks as industrial blight. But here, they became a cherished symbol of the town’s working-class ethos.
Fishermen used them as a lighthouse beacon to guide them home from sea. Local surfers paddled out knowing where the plant’s outflow would warm up the waves. Shop owners sold T-shirts, coffee mugs and paintings bearing their image.
A brewery was named Three Stacks and A Rock. A bistro was dubbed STAX.
But times change. The planet warmed. The power plant became a relic in an era when California is moving toward renewable energy. It shut down eight years ago, and it’s not coming back.
Soon, the smokestacks will come down. Many in the town are heartbroken.
“Everyone comes to Morro Bay to see Three Stacks and a Rock,” said Bud Hurless, 30, as he unloaded a fishing boat on a recent morning.
“And now it’s going to be, ‘Come to Morro Bay for — a rock!’ It sounds pretty bad. I’d be super bummed.”
In many ways, the Morro Bay power plant site represents the evolution of energy in the Golden State.
Built by Pacific Gas and Electric in the 1950s, the plant was first run on oil, and the stacks belched black smoke, leaving soot on cars and homes. It eventually transitioned to natural gas before shutting down in 2014.
Now, Vistra Corp., a Texas-based energy company that owns the site, is proposing building what would be one of the world’s largest lithium-ion battery storage facilities there. And there are ongoing discussions about connecting a planned offshore wind farm to the power grid using existing infrastructure on the property.
“This ‘stacks to storage’ concept transitions a retired fossil fuel site into a renewable energy center repurposing the existing infrastructure, saving time and money,” Vistra Corp. spokesman Brad Watson said in an email.
But the drama over what to do with the smokestacks stands as a harbinger of conflicts to come in California, where state law requires that all of the state’s electricity come from clean energy sources by 2045.
As the state makes that transition, more communities will be forced to deal with the hulking industrial infrastructure that will be left behind.
“Manmade structures have a life cycle,” said Erin Pearse, director of the Initiative for Climate Leadership and Resilience at Cal Poly San Luis Obispo. “There are obviously a lot of advantages to trying to convert these facilities into something else that could be used — maybe in a similar way, maybe in a different way — but at least reused.”
Such decisions are complicated because the sites are often decades old and contaminated. And, in the case of underwater structures such as oil platforms off the coast, marine ecosystems have sprung up on and around them, and removal might be even more harmful, Pearse said.
But the energy transition, he said, is urgently needed because of climate change.
“People are finally starting to get it,” he said. “They’re seeing the fires, they’re seeing the heat waves, they’re seeing all the associated weather events, and it’s forming too strong a pattern to be denied.”
What that transition means for huge, polluting structures has looked different up and down the coast.
In Redondo Beach, the gas-fired AES Corp. power plant on the waterfront has been slated for closure for years but recently had its operational life extended at least through the end of 2023 because of punishing heat waves and potential power shortfalls. Residents have long been fighting for the plant to be demolished and the site made into a public park and for its wetlands to be restored.
And in San Francisco, the waterfront site of the Potrero Power Station that closed in 2011 is undergoing a $2-billion redevelopment that will include the building of about 2,600 housing units, a hotel, and park space. The 300-foot smokestack will be incorporated into the design.
In Morro Bay, the smokestacks loom over a small city of low-slung buildings and 10,700 residents.
Here, the air is briny and the fog rolls in so thick that the stacks can disappear several times a day.
The deteriorating plant, which once provided energy to hundreds of thousands of homes along the Central Coast and in the Central Valley, is filled with asbestos, aging control panels, and seabird poop.
Morro Bay City Manager Scott Collins said it looks like a cross between the nuclear plant where Homer Simpson worked and something from the set of the TV series “Lost.”
“It’s a time warp when you walk in there,” he said. “There’s feces everywhere.”
Last fall, the Morro Bay City Council voted to have the smokestacks torn down.
They stand on private property owned by Vistra Corp., which gave the city the option to keep the smokestacks up — if it took on liability costs and paid to maintain them.
Annual costs would include inspections of up to $50,000 and maintenance of up to $30,000, and the city would have to pay more than $750,000 to place caps atop each one to protect their interiors. Tearing them down on the city’s dime would be $5 million to $10 million, Collins said.
“For a city that’s small like us, where we struggle to pave our streets and take care of our harbor ... we’re not going to take on another asset that has no real economic value,” Collins said. “You can’t turn the stacks into a money generator.”
The city and Vistra came to an agreement: The company will tear down the plant and smokestacks by Dec. 31, 2027, or it will pay Morro Bay $3 million.
The stacks will not be imploded. They will be chipped away, starting at the top, with the concrete pieces dropped down the center of each column.
The Morro Bay power station would house around 180,000 battery modules that would hold energy produced elsewhere and release it to the power grid via an existing PG&E switchyard adjacent to the site. It could power up to 450,000 homes.
And, Collins said, it could store energy generated by an enormous floating wind farm proposed for 20 miles off the coast of Morro Bay.
Delaying the closure of Diablo Canyon would mark a shift for nuclear politics as the climate crisis worsens.
With the Diablo Canyon nuclear plant near San Luis Obispo scheduled to close by 2025, “the need for significant energy storage on the Central Coast is critical,” Vistra said in a planning application.
Despite the potential, Collins said, there are genuine concerns among residents about the demolition of the smokestacks changing the character of the blue-collar community.
They worry about overdevelopment and being priced out of their gorgeous slice of California coast. A common refrain is: Don’t let Morro Bay become too much like ritizier beach towns like Cambria or Carmel.
City officials and Vistra are discussing some kind of monument — maybe a plaque — to honor the smokestacks and the importance of the energy industry in Morro Bay, which incorporated in 1964 after the power plant gave it enough of a tax base to do so.
But a plaque won’t quite quell the heartache.
Residents are quick to offer ideas for what the smokestacks could become. An art installation. An observation deck, perhaps. Some have even suggested running zip lines from the stacks to Morro Rock.
From his counter at the Azhiaziam (pronounced “As high as I am”) surf shop, owner Mike Jones sees the stacks just beyond his front door, and he sells stickers with their likeness.
“They’re part of the skyline,” Jones said. “The sun sets, and they cast shadows. The sunlight goes through them, and the fog drifts by them. Every day, they’re kind of awe inspiring.”
Jones, 49, grew up in Morro Bay and has spent most of his life here, once basking in water released by the old power plant that was so warm it melted the wax of surfboards.
“You were just surfing in, like, Tahiti water,” he said.
He has used Google Maps to see if his shop would be crushed if the smokestacks crashed down; it wouldn’t, but not by much.
When he posted a photo of the smokestacks on April Fool’s Day saying they were coming down that week, people freaked out, saying they planned to drive from as far as Fresno to see them.
This month, a customer from New York came in and was “bagging on” the smokestacks, calling them ugly.
“Someone from New York talking trash on them? I’m like, you know what? Whatever. You don’t need to bash our town,” Jones said.
At the docks across the street, fisherman Bill Blue, 66, unloaded scores of black cod from his boat, the Brita Michell, in the shadow of the smokestacks.
Blue came to Morro Bay from Southern California at 18 in 1974, and he’s been fishing in local waters ever since. When he first started — before he had electronic GPS equipment — he used the flashing red lights atop the stacks to orient himself on the sea.
“Once they take those down, the next thing they’ll want to do is take the rock away,” he said, only half joking. Decades ago, people actually did quarry Morro Rock, including with explosives.
Blue envisions an apocalyptic scene of shop and dock closures and people in hazmat suits when the demolition of the asbestos-laden power plant begins.
As one of Blue’s customers, Tanya Hartley of Santa Barbara, packed 300 pounds of black cod into ice-filled coolers in the back of her Dodge Ram, she said the giant concrete cylinders felt like relics. Hartley, 46, who owns an organic farm, said the planet needs renewable energy, not what the smokestacks represent.
Near Morro Rock — where tourists snapped photos of lounging sea otters as the foghorn bellowed its low, mournful call — Diego Avila stopped to gaze at the smokestacks across the water.
Avila, a 46-year-old psychotherapist from London who was visiting a friend, said that while he could appreciate why locals loved them, they seemed “so at odds with the rest of the scenery.”
“They’re so — random.”
This story originally appeared in Los Angeles Times.