Promoted content

Local realtor reveals how recessions can impact a real estate market

Presented by Brezsny Associates
housing recession
Dax Nollenberger, Realtor at Brezsny Associates
(Brezsny Associates)

The dreaded big R. No, R doesn’t stand for Real Estate, it stands for Recession and as you’ll read below, one doesn’t always impact the other. The big R-word has been thrown around quite frequently of late and it’s got people spooked. Spooked that this real estate market is going to take a turn for the worse. Some buyers have even used the term “crash”. While people are rightfully cautious because of our last significant recession, recency bias is playing a major role in how the real estate market has reacted to news of a potential upcoming recession. We, as humans, are flawed creatures. We tend to place a disproportionate amount of weight on more recent events i.e., recency bias.

I don’t know for certain that we are, in fact, headed for a recession. I do know, however, that it doesn’t necessarily mean that it’ll impact the housing market if we do enter one. The bulk of the real estate impact is already occurring as interest rates are hiked to combat inflation (potentially causing a recession). Contrary to recent viewpoints from our experience with the 2008 housing crash, historically, real estate fares well during recession times. In fact, as you’ll read below, prices typically continue to rise.

×

In this Dax’s Data, I dive into the impact that recessions have had on the national, regional, state, and local markets. Before we dive into the impact of recessions, let’s first define a recession. A recession is defined as two consecutive quarters of negative GDP. GDP (Gross Domestic Product) is the monetary value of the final goods and services produced in the USA. If we produce less than the previous quarter for two consecutive months then we are in a recession.

Data pulled nationally/regionally from NAR, state from CAR, and locally from SCCAR & The MLS.
(Brezsny Associates)

Recessions typically last 1-2 years. There have been fifteen recessions in the last 100 years. The data I am going to present spans back to 1968. Eight recessions have occurred in that timeframe and, on average, last 10.6 months. The metric that I’ll be focusing on is Single-Family Median Home Price. While I realize that there are plenty of other metrics that help determine Real Estate market strength, prioritizing prices gets to the crux of the question, “will prices crash”?

Let’s look holistically, then we will dive into each individual recession.

The blue boxes indicate a recession period.
The blue boxes indicate a recession period. The data for each particular metric starts from the point at which we have available data.
(Brezsny Associates)

The data for each particular metric starts from the point at which we have available data. A couple of things become clear when you zoom out, first, there aren’t any noticeable dips in prices during a recession with the exception of 2008. The second observation is just how much, comparatively (from a dollar perspective), the median home price has grown in Santa Cruz County, California, and the West region as a whole. More on appreciation in another blog.

Let’s dig into each recession.

Recession of 1969 - 1970

Relatively mild overall and lasted 11 months from December 1969 to November 1970. We have the US and California yearly data. The US median home price in 1970 increased 5.5% from the year previous. This was a lower increase than 1968 to 1969 (8.5%) and 1970 to 1971 (7.8%). California experienced only a 1.7% median price increase over the previous year.

Conclusion: The recession had minimal impact on real estate as both the National and State Median home prices increased from the previous year.

Median Price Change: Positive

Side note: the median home price in California in 1970 was $24,640… mind blown!

Recession of 1973 - 1975

The result of the 1973 oil crisis, this recession lasted 16 months from November 1973 to March 1975. We have the US and California yearly data. During the 16 months that spanned over three calendar years, the real estate market had explosive growth both nationally and at the state level in California. The 1973 US median home price was $28,900, up 8.2% from the year previous. It then grew another 10.7% in 1974 and 10.3% in 1975. California had similar Median price growth, gaining 9.2% from 1972 to 1973 and another 10% and 20.2% in subsequent years.

Conclusion: The recession had virtually no negative impact on real estate pricing nationally or in California. Some of the growth can be attributed to the high inflation rate of the 1970s.

Median Price Change: Positive

Recession of 1980

The result of raised interest rates (as high as 20% in 1981) by Fed Chair, Paul Volcker, to fight the inflation of the 1970s. This recession lasted 6 months from January 1980 to July 1980. We have the US and California yearly data. The median home prices seem to be minimally affected by this brief recession. From 1979 to 1980, US Median home price rose 11.7% while California rose 20.2%.

Conclusion: Home prices jumped significantly in 1980, partly the result of inflation. California far outpaced inflation numbers (CA real estate is a great hedge against inflation, historically).

Median Price Change: Positive

Recession of 1981 - 1982

Related to the 1980 recession, the recession of 1981-1982 was considered the main course after a 1980 appetizer. Caused by the 1979 energy crisis and a tightening of monetary policy, this recession lasted 16 months from July 1981 to November 1982. We have the US and California yearly data. While housing price growth certainly slowed, we still saw year-over-year growth in Median home price for both California and the USA from 1980 to 1981 (CA 8.2%, US 6.8%) and 1981 to 1982 (CA 3.8%, US 2.1%).

Conclusion: Home prices still grew during the 1981-1982 recession but inflation was historically high in ’79, ’80, and ’81. Home price growth could not keep up with the inflation rate.

Median Price Change: Positive

Recession of the Early 1990’s

The result of the Fed’s rate hikes to combat inflation from 1986-1989. This recession lasted 8 months from July 1990 to March 1991. We have the US and California yearly data. US Median prices grew 2.9% from 1989 to 1990 and 5.5% from 1990 to 1991. California’s Median price decreased 1.2% from 1989 to 1990 and increased 3.6% from 1990 to 1991.

Conclusion: Small price growth for the national home prices and net-positive growth over two years for California.

Median Price Change: Positive

Recession of the Early 2000’s

single family media housing prices 2001 recession
(Brezsny Associates)

The result of the Dot-com bubble (among other factors). This recession lasted 8 months from March 2001 to November 2001. We have US, regional, California, and local monthly and yearly data. Year-over-year, every area performed well in terms of median price growth. US median price grew 6.3%, California grew 8.7%, and Santa Cruz County grew 11%. Although looking at the monthly data, prices stayed relatively flat during the period from March to November 2001.

Conclusion: The year-over-year growth was really strong. When zooming in, the majority of the growth occurred just prior to and just after the defined recession period.

Median Price Change: Positive Y-O-Y, Flat during recession months

The Great Recession

single-family media housing prices 2008 recession
(Brezsny Associates)

Also known as the housing crash, this recession certainly did have an impact on pricing. First, though, let’s discuss briefly why the recession occurred. A lack of lending regulation and reckless lending practices led to MANY unqualified buyers getting qualified for way more than they could afford. When the market shifted, all those borrowers defaulted on their loans. This recession lasted 18 months from Dec 2007 to June 2009. We have US, regional, California, and local monthly and yearly data. Every region in the US had two consecutive years of declining median home price. The US was -9.8% from 2007 to 2008, and -12.5% from 2008 to 2009. California saw massive loss in median home price in both 2007 and 2008. California’s median home price dropped 37.8% from 2007 to 2008 and 21.1% from 2008 to 2009. Santa Cruz County was -23% from 2007 to 2008 and -15% from 2008 to 2009.

Conclusion: The real estate market isn’t recession-proof if it is the cause of the recession. Fortunately, proper legislation and regulation will ensure that a subprime mortgage recession won’t occur again as lending practices have been strengthened and buyers are highly qualified. Another important note is that this recession particularly affected the higher-price areas like California.

Median Price Change: Negative

COVID-19 Recession

This may be the nation’s quickest recession. Brought on by a global pandemic, the drop was sharp but the recovery was fierce. This recession lasted two months from Feb 2020 to April 2020. We have US, regional, California, and local monthly and yearly data. The worst month of this recession for real estate actually occurred in May of 2020 when the median price dropped over 10% locally. After that, when the interest rates plummeted, the market took off at a record pace.

Conclusion: Uncertainty creates fear which creates inaction. Once clarity was provided and quantitative easing improved loan affordability, demand soared. The lesson is action during inactive times is when you can get great deals.

Median Price Change: Positive

Wow, that was a lot. Let’s draw some quick conclusions from the data. Those that are anticipating and waiting for a “crash” in the market, think again. Those that are too nervous to buy because everyone keeps throwing out the big R, don’t fret.

The benefits of real estate go beyond the pride of ownership. It’s also a great inflation hedge (as noted by continuous price growth), has great tax benefits, allows you to build equity from debt paydown (rather than paying rent), and did I mention that real estate performs well during recessions?

Recessions do not mean that housing prices decrease. This isn’t to say that recessions don’t have some impact on housing but through eight analyzed recessions, only during one of them did prices actually drop. The more likely scenario is a brief slowing of growth or a temporary flattening of the trend. For those buyers willing to take the plunge, there are opportunities out there. For those waiting for the market plunge, the opportunity is going to pass you by.

Give me a call so I can help navigate you through these uncertain times.

DISCOVER LOCAL BEAUTY
  • General
    Connect with Dax from Brezsny Associates
    Home is where your story begins. Let the experts at Brezsny Associates help you fulfill your real estate dreams.

Latest Stories