Quick Take

California Gov. Gavin Newsom recently commuted the death sentences of 584 inmates, including David Carpenter, known as the Trailside Killer, who murdered two women in Santa Cruz County and five people in Marin County. A former Santa Cruz County investigator recalls investigative details that helped bring Carpenter to justice and reflects on the governor’s decision.

The so-called Trailside Killer was sentenced to death for murdering and sexually assaulting two women in Santa Cruz County and is among the felons whose sentences Gov. Gavin Newsom recently commuted to life in prison.

David Carpenter, a San Francisco native, also killed four women and one man in Marin County and shot a third person in the Santa Cruz Mountains, the boyfriend of one of the women killed, who survived a gunshot wound to the throat. The three victims in this county were from Davis and San Jose and were all 20 years old. 

On Nov. 5, Newsom announced he was commuting the state’s 584 pending death penalty sentences to terms of life in prison without possibility of parole. Carpenter is one of 382 inmates with multiple felony convictions, whose commutations require additional approval from four California Supreme Court justices, according to the governor’s list of intended clemency recipients. 

The Trailside Killer began raping and murdering women in 1980, at Point Reyes National Seashore and on Mount Tamalpais in Marin County. A few months later, in 1981, he terrorized three hikers along the tree-lined trails of Henry Cowell and Big Basin state parks. 

The Carpenter victims in Santa Cruz County were Ellen Marie Hansen, whom he attempted to rape and then shot in Henry Cowell Redwoods State Park; her boyfriend, Steven Russell Haertle, who was shot and survived; and Heather Roxanne Scaggs of San Jose, who was murdered in Big Basin Redwoods State Park. 

Carpenter had reportedly lured Scaggs there to look at a used car for sale, after the two met at a Hayward trade school where Carpenter taught. 

He had committed several violent sex crimes before the rapes and murders that led to his gas-chamber sentence, and had been released from prison in 1949 after serving a nine-year sentence for rape and parole violations, according to a 2010 San Francisco Chronicle story. After a 32-year record of violence, he returned to his parents’ Glen Park home in San Francisco, “gray-haired, bespectacled and [speaking] with a severe stutter,” Jaxon Van Derbeken reported. 

Unfortunately, an early eyewitness description of Carpenter led Marin County investigators to believe he was much younger than 50, his age when he began stalking, raping and murdering people in popular hiking areas in Marin and Santa Cruz counties. 

Now, at age 96, Carpenter’s commutation remains uncertain. He is the oldest inmate on what is now a figurative death row; he is incarcerated at the California Health Care Facility in Stockton. A spokesman for that prison-system facility did not return calls seeking comment. 

Carpenter was arrested May 14, 1981, by Santa Cruz investigators working with a task force ultimately based at the Presidio in San Francisco. He was convicted in separate trials moved to Los Angeles and San Diego counties due to the cases’ notoriety. His death sentences came in 1984 for the Santa Cruz County killings and four years later for the Marin County killings. 

The man who led the Santa Cruz County Sheriff’s Office investigation is retired and for years has served in leadership roles supporting veterans in Santa Cruz. 

In an interview last week, former detective sergeant Stoney Brook called Carpenter a brutal rapist and killer and a “classic sociopath.” 

Brook said he was struck by Carpenter’s cruelty, recalling particularly gruesome slayings and the way the victims’ bodies appeared and were positioned when found. Most were buried off trails in shallow graves or quickly covered with brush. 

“He was brutal,” Brook said. “Most people don’t start out raping people like he did, and there were so many backstops. But he fell through every crack there was.”

An only child, Carpenter’s alcoholic father and his domineering mother were physically and emotionally abusive, according to newspaper accounts after his arrest. His mother forbade him from going outside and insisted he practice violin and ballet. His stuttering and odd clothing provided by his parents made him a target of bullying. Many years later, he would tell a girlfriend his friends called him “Devious Dave.”

Testifying at a preliminary hearing, the former girlfriend also said Carpenter read The Wall Street Journal, often walked his parents’ dog and once advised a bank robber, after selling him a gun he had used to kill someone, that the man should invest his robbery proceeds rather than squander them, according to a 1982 Santa Cruz Sentinel story by Peggy Townsend. 

David Carpenter, the accused Trailside Killer, listens during testimony in a Los Angeles court on June 1, 1984.
David Carpenter, the accused Trailside Killer, listens during testimony in a Los Angeles court on June 1, 1984. Credit: Associated Press

During the penalty phase of Carpenter’s trial, defense attorney Larry Biggam asked that his client be spared the death penalty, according to a 1984 United Press International story. Biggam argued that Carpenter’s violence was “greatly influenced by his traumas” and that he had been “damned at an early age.” His family was one of the “worst messes” state officials had seen, said Biggam, a noted criminal defense attorney and later partner at the main public defender firm in Santa Cruz County. 

Brook said he saw no redeeming qualities in Carpenter. But he also said he doesn’t put much stock in the deterrent effect of the death penalty. 

“It’s about time someone stood up and made the call,” he said of Newsom’s decision. 

Aside from numerous legal battles, California voters opted to retain the death penalty at least four times after various federal and state Supreme Court decisions halted executions, according to the California Department of Corrections. Executions were effectively paused from roughly 1967 to 1992, and voters chose to keep the death penalty in place through statewide propositions in 1972, 1978, 2012 and 2016. 

The California District Attorneys Association in October issued a strong rebuke of the governor’s anticipated clemency action. The Santa Cruz County District Attorney’s Office did not return calls seeking comment. 

Another former investigator who worked to stop Carpenter said the death penalty is necessary. 

a headshot of Sam Robustelli, currently a member of the governing board of the Boulder Creek Fire Protection District, investigated David Carpenter while with the Santa Cruz County District Attorney’s Office
Sam Robustelli, currently a member of the governing board of the Boulder Creek Fire Protection District, investigated David Carpenter while with the Santa Cruz County District Attorney’s Office. Credit: Boulder Creek Fire Protection District

“It’s about what the victims and survivors are owed,” said Sam Robustelli, a retired inspector with the Santa Cruz County District Attorney’s Office and a longtime volunteer, former chief and current board member of Boulder Creek Fire Protection District. 

“A life sentence doesn’t cut it for me,” he said. “This person has been able to eat, drink, sleep, go to the doctor and be cared for, and there’s a huge cost factor for that. But it doesn’t replace a person’s life. You never get that back.” 

Investigators and others credit Hansen’s struggle against Carpenter with saving her boyfriend’s life, and an annual award honors her memory at UC Davis, where her father was a professor of veterinary science. Brook remembers Haertle pounding his fists on the table after being shown an image of the killer, still unable to speak because of the gunshot wound to his throat.

A Ben Lomond woman also played a role, identifying Carpenter after remembering him as a purser on a ship en route to Japan. She told detectives he had made inappropriate sexual comments to her 14-year-old daughter. 

The final breakthrough linking Carpenter to the Henry Cowell crimes came when the former girlfriend told Brook she had given Carpenter the distinctive custom jacket witnesses described him wearing. The woman said a former boss had made just 12 of the “Olympic Beer Drinking Team” jackets for her employees. 

Carpenter’s heinous saga came just a few years after three other serial killers were operating in the county. 

In 1970 to 1973, the murderers’ killing sprees, separately yet at times simultaneously, earned the small county the morbid moniker of “Murder Capital of the World.” 

Two of the three mass murderers from the early 1970s have died. John Linley Frazier died by suicide in prison in 2009, at age 63. Herbert Mullin died in prison of natural causes in 2022, at age 75. Edmund Emil Kemper III, also known as the Co-ed Killer, is serving a life sentence. 

Kemper was spared a death sentence by the timing of the court ruling. He was sentenced to life in prison on Nov. 9, 1973, roughly two years after the California Supreme Court ruled that the death penalty was cruel and unusual punishment. A state law signed by Gov. Ronald Reagan reversed that decision and took effect less than two months later, on Jan. 1, 1974.  

Brook worked as a deputy during those murder sprees, too. He remembers being the smallest deputy on hand one day at the Kemper’s infamous Aptos home in 1973 and shimmying through a bathroom window to find the bodies of his mother and her friend. Kemper had buried his mother’s head in the backyard. He was convicted of killing 10 people, including six young women. 

Condemned inmate David Carpenter, also known as the Trailside Killer, watches television in his cell on death row at San Quentin State Prison on Dec. 29, 2015.
Condemned inmate David Carpenter, also known as the Trailside Killer, watches television in his cell on death row at San Quentin State Prison on Dec. 29, 2015. Credit: Ben Margot / Associated Press

But Brook worked on Carpenter’s case far longer, through Carpenter’s 1984 death sentence. 

He said it was remarkable how many of the murderers were caught, without even knowing about DNA, sometimes with investigators who had just six weeks of academy training. He said they didn’t even have radios that worked that well. 

It was a team effort to catch Carpenter, he said. He praised San Jose, San Francisco and local investigators, saying Ray Belgard, then the lead investigator for Santa Cruz County District Attorney’s Office, jump-started the successful task force that ended in his arrest.

In Marin County, the killings left favorite trails north of San Francisco mostly empty of hikers for months, according to a 1986 Associated Press story. 

There, Carpenter was convicted of killing Richard Stowers, 19, of Petaluma; his fiancée, Cynthia Moreland, 18, of Cotati; Anne Alderson, 26, of San Rafael; Diane O’Connell, 22, of San Jose; and Shauna May, 25, of San Francisco. 

Brook is quoted in the 1990 nonfiction book “The Sleeping Lady: The Trailside Murders Above the Golden Gate” by Robert Graysmith. Graysmith, a former San Francisco Chronicle cartoonist, is more renowned for his book on the still-unidentified Zodiac Killer, who is believed to have killed five people in San Francisco, Benicia and Vallejo in 1968 and 1969. 

Carpenter reportedly claimed he was the Zodiac, but that was debunked because he was in prison during some of the later Zodiac slayings.

Brook said Carpenter never said much to detectives after his arrest in San Francisco, but pleaded out instead. Despite his doubts about the death penalty’s deterrence, he imagines Carpenter might have been dreading the day when the needle might reach him. 

“I can’t believe he’s managed to hold on this long,” Brook said.

Have something to say? Lookout welcomes letters to the editor, within our policies, from readers. Guidelines here.