Quick Take

Lookout answers readers’ questions about the 55-foot fin whale that washed ashore at Cowell Beach, including why it couldn’t be saved, why its carcass was buried at the Dimeo Lane landfill and what researchers hope to learn from necropsy tests.

Q: Where is the whale now? What happened to it?

A: After the fin whale carcass was removed from Santa Cruz’s Cowell Beach last Thursday night, it was transported to the Dimeo Lane Resource Recovery Facility to be buried.

“You can’t just move the whale and then move the whale again, so it had to go to where it was gonna be buried,” said Robin Dunkin, faculty director of the Long Marine Laboratory Marine Mammal Stranding Network at UC Santa Cruz. 

Dunkin explained that while the whale’s burial site was not ideal, it was the only viable option. 

“We worked for a few hours while you saw all of us down there on the beach, we were trying to make a lot of phone calls to find either a private ranch or perhaps UCSC land where the whale could be buried and then perhaps later the bones recovered,” she said. “Because the City of Santa Cruz owns the resource recovery center at Dimeo Lane, they worked together to locate a place for the whale and they made it possible for us to collect as much science as we possibly could.”

Researchers performed a necropsy, collecting tissue and biological sampling for diagnostic testing, including histopathology, to help determine the cause of death. Results will be released publicly when they become available. 

A: Possibly. While researchers await necropsy results, the fin whale’s cause of illness remains undetermined. What has been confirmed is the mammal’s severe emaciation, including a prolonged period of malnutrition. However, researchers don’t yet know what factors contributed to its condition. 

“It’s hard to narrow down any one environmental factor. Certainly, when we see an animal with a long-term illness, it’s always possible that there’s a combination of factors that could have led to that illness. Oftentimes, diseases or pathogens are influenced by the environment,” Dunkin said.

“Sometimes it’s clear, like we see we’ve had a huge domoic acid year this year. We are sending those samples to the lab that’s gonna process them tomorrow – so, we should know by the end of the week whether the animal had domoic acid in its body or not. The short answer is that we won’t know until we get all the tests back.”

Dunkin also noted that researchers found no plastic in the whale’s stomach, ruling out plastic ingestion as the cause of death. Examinations also concluded that a ship strike was not responsible for the whale’s condition. 

Q: Is there any relation between the whale’s death and the E. coli outbreak found in Santa Cruz County waters?

A: Most likely not.

Q: Why couldn’t they just push the fin whale back into the ocean? 

A: Although returning a whale carcass to the ocean is generally preferable when conditions allow, pushing this specific fin whale back into the water would have been unsafe because of its size, weight and how recently it had died. Researchers determined the whale was 55 feet long and weighed an estimated 58,000 pounds, making it a huge risk to tow back out to sea.

Dunkin cited three key reasons why this recovery method was not possible:

  1. There was a huge swell coming in, making it difficult for vessel assist partners to tow the whale far enough out into the bay to ensure that it wouldn’t just wash back to shore. 
  2. When a whale carcass decomposes, it accumulates gases inside its body that make it float, allowing for a safe release back into the ocean. Because this fin whale died on the same morning that it was found beached, its body was too fresh and heavy to transport into the sea without risking the sinking of the towboats.
  3. Since a storm was coming in, the beach was likely to flood, which would almost certainly have caused the whale carcass to crash into the pier or damage the wharf.

Removing the carcass from the beach entirely was the most logical choice to avoid these issues.

Q: Why couldn’t the whale be saved? 

A: When the whale was found on Cowell Beach, it was already in critical condition. Dunkin explained that it is extremely rare for fin whales to appear near shore in this part of Monterey Bay, and when they do it is a very bad sign.

“The situation with large whales like this is that they don’t come to shore for no reason,” Dunkin said. “They live their lives out in very deep water.

“When they come to shore like that, it is because they’re really sick. This whale was very, very sick. It had almost no liquid left in its liver. It had been clearly ill for quite a long time. It was really only on the beach because it had lost the strength that it needed to continue swimming.”

Dunkin emphasized that it would have been extremely dangerous for rescuers to try to administer any kind of care, despite their desire to help the suffering mammal. 

“A whale that size is extremely dangerous, and I would not want anyone to attempt to push even a smaller animal back into the water,” she said. “More often than not, that is going to result in the animal drowning and prolonging the suffering.”

Q: How did the whale end up in Santa Cruz? Did it have anything to do with migration patterns?

A: Because of Santa Cruz’s location at the edge of the Monterey Canyon, the area attracts a wide variety of marine mammals. Large whales often come closer than normal to the shore because of the deep water in the middle of the bay.

According to Dunkin, the fin whale’s appearance in Santa Cruz wasn’t necessarily related to migration.

“Fin whales are not like humpbacks or gray whales that have more of a migration pattern,” she said. “They are attracted here and it’s not unusual to find them, but it is unusual for them to beach. There’s only been a few fin whales that have beached over the past decade in San Francisco and the Monterey Bay.”

Q: When can we expect an update on lab results from the whale necropsy?

A: The timeline depends on how much work is required for each test.

“We should have some results about domoic acid by the end of the week,” Dunkin told Lookout. “As soon as we have that data, we’ll put out a little press release or something by the end of this week or maybe next week.

“The other tests take longer. There’s a lot of preparation that has to go into prepping all the tissues, and then a pathologist will read them out, and that takes some time. So I think we’re hopeful that we’ll have something within a month – it might be five or six weeks.”

Q: Were Lookout’s photos generated by artificial intelligence?

A: No. The photos Lookout has published of the fin whale were taken at Cowell Beach by Lookout photojournalist Kevin Painchaud. 

Have something to say? Lookout welcomes letters to the editor, within our policies, from readers. Guidelines here.

Kate Lipsky is a fourth-year literature student at UC Santa Cruz with a passion for making accessible, reliable information available to a wide audience. She is joining Lookout Santa Cruz as a digital...