Quick Take
Ashtyn Davis’ dream of playing for his hometown 49ers took a disappointing turn Sunday when San Francisco released the Santa Cruz native in its move to a 53-man roster. But because Davis is a vested veteran and the 49ers kept just three safeties, his release could be temporary — leaving open a path for him to return before the season opener.
For Ashtyn Davis, the dream of playing for his hometown NFL team has taken an unexpected turn — at least for now.
The San Francisco 49ers released the Santa Cruz native Sunday as they trimmed their roster to the NFL-mandated 53 players. Davis had signed a one-year contract with the 49ers in June after spending his entire NFL career playing for teams on the East Coast, including the New York Jets and Miami Dolphins. Being released does not necessarily mean Davis’ time with the 49ers is over. There are numerous scenarios that might yet give the 29-year-old veteran a roster spot in San Francisco.
A numbers game at safety
The 49ers ultimately kept just three safeties on their 53-man roster: Ji’Ayir Brown, Malik Mustapha and Marques Sigle. That’s an unusually thin group for a position where injuries can quickly create a need for additional depth.
Davis had competed throughout training camp for a spot behind Brown, Mustapha and Sigle. His experience was particularly valuable because he has spent six seasons in the NFL and has played both defense and special teams.
The timing of Mustapha’s return might have played a role in the decision to cut Davis. Mustapha missed much of training camp with a hamstring injury, leaving the safety competition unsettled heading into the preseason finale. Davis was very much in the mix during that period.
But with the 49ers expecting Mustapha to be available for the start of the season, San Francisco apparently decided it could live with less depth at safety.
Special teams might have mattered, too
Another factor in the final roster decisions could have been special teams.
The 49ers kept veteran defensive back Siran Neal, who can play multiple defensive back positions and has extensive special teams experience. The 49ers’ own roster breakdown lists Neal among their seven cornerbacks/defensive backs, while Brown, Mustapha and Sigle make up the three-player safety group.
For a team trying to squeeze 53 players onto a roster, versatility can be decisive.
Davis has plenty of NFL experience, but San Francisco apparently valued the ability to use Neal in multiple roles and on special teams more than carrying a fourth natural safety.
Davis’ release could be temporary
This is the part that makes Davis’ situation particularly interesting. Because Davis is a vested veteran, meaning he has completed four or more seasons in the league, the 49ers did not have to put him through the same waiver process as younger players. Vested veterans released during the roster reduction become free agents rather than being subject to waivers.
That gives San Francisco considerably more flexibility. The 49ers can now make other roster moves, including moving injured players to injured reserve, and potentially bring Davis back afterward.
San Francisco already demonstrated how much roster maneuvering can happen around cutdown day. The team placed wide receiver Christian Kirk and offensive lineman Austen Pleasants on injured reserve with designations to return, while other injured players were placed on IR without that designation.
The NFL’s rules allow teams to designate a maximum of two players for return from a reserve list during the final roster reduction.
That means some of Sunday’s cuts can be viewed as temporary roster gymnastics rather than a definitive end to a player’s relationship with the team.
Why the NFL’s IR rules matter
The NFL’s injured-reserve rules make cutdown day especially complicated. If a player is placed on injured reserve before the final 53-man roster is established, he generally cannot simply be brought back during the season. To preserve a player’s ability to return, teams can carry him on the initial 53-man roster and then place him on IR with a return designation.
Players placed on IR with the ability to return must miss at least four regular-season games.
That creates an incentive for teams to temporarily keep certain injured players on the 53-man roster, then move them to IR once the deadline passes.
It also can create temporary roster openings.
For Davis, that could be significant.
The 49ers are already dealing with a number of injuries, and their initial roster is likely to change before the season opener. San Francisco’s first game is Sept. 10 against the Los Angeles Rams at Melbourne Cricket Ground in Australia.
A disappointing turn, but not necessarily the end
Davis’ release is undoubtedly a disappointing development for a player who grew up in Santa Cruz and spent four years at Cal before beginning his NFL career with the New York Jets.
He was originally selected by the Jets in the third round of the 2020 NFL draft and has played 84 NFL games, including 34 starts. Last season with Miami, he played in 15 games and started 12, recording 65 tackles, four passes defended and an interception.
So while Davis won’t begin the 2026 season on San Francisco’s initial 53-man roster, his release might be more of a roster-management decision than a final judgment on his ability.
For a hometown player who spent the summer trying to make the 49ers, there is still a chance this isn’t the last chapter.
Have something to say? Lookout welcomes letters to the editor, within our policies, from readers. Guidelines here.
