A Lookout View: Renee Golder for Santa Cruz City Council District 6

Editor’s note: A Lookout View is the opinion of our Community Voices opinion section, written by our editorial board, which consists of Community Voices Editor Jody K. Biehl and Lookout Founder Ken Doctor. Our goal is to connect the dots we see in the news and offer a bigger-picture view — all intended to see Santa Cruz County meet the challenges of the day and to shine a light on issues we believe must be on the public agenda. These views are distinct and independent from the work of our newsroom and its reporting. Read more here.

Local government works best when experience, relationships and institutional knowledge are already in place on Day 1. In this race for Santa Cruz City Council District 6, Renee Golder offers that readiness in a way that stands out.

Golder brings years of public service experience in Santa Cruz, along with her working relationships with leaders across agencies, community organizations and local stakeholders essential to getting things done. In city government, effectiveness often comes down to knowing who to call, how systems actually operate and how to turn community priorities into action. Golder’s career in education and as the longtime principal of Bay View Elementary School reflects that kind of practical, hands-on understanding. She is currently a member of the board of directors of the League of California Cities (she is the Monterey Bay representative), where she has actively urged state lawmakers to pause changes to building codes and has advocated for more workforce housing initiatives. She is now working on questions of e-bike policy and addressing the rising cost of fire insurance, all issues vital in Santa Cruz.

Her strength is not just familiarity with issues, but the ability to operate within the system to deliver results. That matters in a city poised for growth, where coordination across housing, infrastructure, business support and social services is increasingly complex and time-sensitive. 

Golder is a straight shooter, something we and her current council colleagues see as a strength. She always says what she thinks and – in the recent debate over Flock Safety automated license-plate readers – has shown an ability to listen to and vote according to her constituents’ concerns, even when they contrast with her own views. We are also impressed with her evolving understanding of tensions with UC Santa Cruz and her belief that collaboration, like on the Delaware Avenue complex, is the way to move forward. 

She is among the most conservative voices on the current board and said she remains proud of the council’s work to end the Ross and other unmanaged homeless encampments. She said the success of these policies has led other city leaders to call Santa Cruz looking for advice. 

Gabriella Noack, by contrast, represents a newer, more progressive and emerging voice in local politics. She is energetic, articulate and clearly engaged in civic issues, and she has shown promise as a thoughtful future leader. Her command of policy conversations and willingness to engage on local challenges suggest she is building toward a meaningful role in the community. She is 24 and set to graduate from UCSC this fall. We hope she stays in Santa Cruz and gets involved in other public bodies. There is much work to be done opening passageways between the city and the campus, and that could be one path for her. Her openness and willingness to share her personal story as a child of open adoption is authentic and refreshing. We hope she builds on it and that her lived experience continues to feed her political journey. 

Lookout’s election forum helped highlight the gap that often exists between policy understanding and deep, ground-level familiarity with the full range of local stakeholders and day-to-day economic realities in the district. That kind of familiarity takes time, sustained engagement and repeated interaction across the community.

This race ultimately comes down to timing and readiness. Noack is a candidate to watch, and she would benefit from continuing to build experience and connections in local civic life. Many voters would likely welcome seeing her run again in the future after further deepening her community engagement.

But right now, the county is facing immediate challenges that require experienced hands and established working relationships. Golder is our choice. 

Have something to say? Lookout welcomes letters to the editor, within our policies, from readers. Guidelines here.