When it comes to managing your money, most people start with the same question: Should I go with a bank or a credit union? At a glance, the two look alike. Both offer savings accounts, loans, and credit cards, but behind the scenes, credit unions operate on an entirely different model. The way they’re structured—and who they exist to serve—can make a meaningful difference in your financial experience.
Let’s break it down:
From 19th Century Germany to Today’s Credit Unions
The idea of a credit union isn’t new, and actually dates back to Germany in the mid-1800s, where communities formed cooperative financial groups to help neighbors access fair loans and savings opportunities. These early cooperatives were built on a simple principle: when people pool their resources, more opportunities are available for everyone.
The idea spread across Europe and eventually to North America, inspiring the Federal Credit Union Act of 1934. Signed into law during the Great Depression, it allowed credit unions to form across the United States, giving working families a safe, community-based alternative to for-profit banking. Nearly a century later, that same cooperative spirit still defines credit unions today.
Ownership: Who’s in Charge Matters
Banks are typically owned by shareholders and operate as for-profit businesses. Their goal is to generate returns for investors. Credit unions, on the other hand, are not-for-profit cooperatives owned by their members.
When you open an account at a credit union, you’re not just depositing money but buying a share of ownership. That’s why credit unions use terms like “share account” instead of “savings account” and “share certificate” instead of “certificate of deposit.” You literally own a small piece of your credit union, which gives you a voice in how it’s run and allows profits to be returned to members through better rates and lower fees.
Think of it like this: at a bank, you’re a customer. At a credit union, you’re a co-owner.
Purpose: Profits vs. People
Banks are designed to earn profits for their shareholders, but credit unions exist to serve their members and strengthen their communities. Instead of distributing earnings to investors, credit unions reinvest them through lower loan rates, higher savings yields, fewer fees, and community programs that make a tangible local impact.
While many banks also give back to the areas they serve, community support isn’t just a marketing initiative for credit unions; it is part of their mission.
Service: Local Roots, Personal Touch
Credit unions are known for their member-focused approach. Decisions such as approving a loan or setting a fee are often made locally by people who understand the community’s needs. That local insight can make a big difference when you’re trying to buy a home, start a small business, or rebuild credit.
Banks, especially national ones, tend to have vast networks and resources, which can be convenient if you travel often. But credit unions combine that hometown-connection with access to shared ATM networks and modern digital tools, so you can bank almost anywhere while still supporting a local institution. This is done through a vast network of cooperation between credit unions across the globe.
Access and Membership
Credit unions used to have strict membership requirements, such as working for a certain employer or belonging to a specific organization, but today many are community-based. That means if you live, work, or go to school in a certain area, you can join. Once you’re a member, you’re a member for life, even if you move out of the area.
Banks, meanwhile, are typically open to anyone, but may charge higher fees or require larger minimum balances to get started.
Technology and Innovation
It’s a common misconception that credit unions are “old school.” In reality, most offer the same digital conveniences as banks, including mobile check deposit, tap-to-pay, and online account management, with the added benefit of human help when you need it.
The Bottom Line
The difference between a bank and a credit union ultimately comes down to purpose and people. Banks focus on profits for shareholders. Credit unions focus on people helping people, a philosophy that has been around since the 1800s and continues to shape how millions of Americans manage their money today.
Whether you choose a bank or a credit union, the most important thing is to find a financial partner that shares your values and helps you reach your goals. When it comes to your money, you deserve more than a place to keep it; you deserve a partner who’s invested in you.
About Bay Federal Credit Union
Bay Federal Credit Union is a full-service, not-for-profit financial institution that serves over 95,000 members and 2,700 local businesses and nonprofit organizations throughout Santa Cruz, San Benito, and Monterey counties. With more than $1.8 billion in assets, Bay Federal is the largest member-owned financial institution in the region. The organization has been proudly serving its members and the community since 1957. Bay Federal is a certified Community Development Financial Institution, with a primary mission of promoting community development alongside their financial activities. Bay Federal has an award-winning employee volunteer program in which employees have given their own money and volunteer for numerous local schools, nonprofit organizations, and community events each year.
MORE FROM BAY FEDERAL
